Chelsea’s Juan Mata Conundrum

This weekend’s first Premier League clash is a repeat of one of last season’s outstanding matches. Chelsea’s 4-2 victory over Tottenham Hotspur was much less comfortable than the scoreline would suggest – an amazingly open, topsy-turvy game was decided in stoppage time, in Andre Villas-Boas’ first meeting against his former club.

The star was one of his favourite players at Chelsea – Juan Mata. The Spaniard became his key attacking weapon during his half-season at Stamford Bridge, and it was inevitable that he’d play a crucial part in the victory. He scored two goals, taking Chelsea from 2-1 down to 2-3 up, and then assisted the fourth for Daniel Sturridge.

But Mata will almost certainly be absent from Chelsea’s starting XI for this weekend’s battle. Clearly out of favour with Jose Mourinho, not even making the 18-man squad for the win over Fulham last weekend, Mata’s absence is extraordinarily considering he was named Chelsea’s Player of the Season in May. There are, it seems, three separate factors in Mata’s exclusion.

The first are tactical concerns about his style. Although perfect as a number ten in a side that played relatively high up the pitch, Mourinho has changed Chelsea’s football this season, and favours more of a fast-paced approach. The 1-0 defeat to Everton demonstrated that Mata isn’t entirely comfortable playing on the break – he kept receiving the ball in promising situations, yet doesn’t have that burst of pace and immediacy required.  “He played against Everton from the start and you can analyse his performance,” Mourinho said pointedly.

In that respect, it’s entirely understandable that Mourinho favours Oscar as the number ten. Indeed, it’s worth remembering that when Roberto Di Matteo was selecting Mata, Oscar and Eden Hazard in the same side, he broadly favoured that approach. Oscar would play a clever tactical role in the centre, Mata would move inside from the flank – that’s what happened in the 4-2 win last season.

But Mourinho’s concerns about Mata are more specific, and concern his lack of defensive work. He will play “only when he adapts to what we want,” Mourinho said. “I’m not ready to ask Oscar to track opposing full-backs, I want the other two players, from the side, to learn how to do things they were not ready to do before.”

Which, reading between the lines, means he wants Mata to become better at nullifying opposition full-backs. It broadly makes sense, then, that Mourinho hasn’t used Mata against Fulham or Manchester United, who both have decent attacking full-backs, and that against Everton he was used centrally, so he didn’t have to deal with Seamus Coleman or Leighton Baines. The home game against Aston Villa, one match where Chelsea didn’t face dangerous full-backs, was when Mata did start out wide.

It’s ironic, however, that the defining moment of Chelsea’s trip to Spurs last year was the final goal. Mata had been squabbling with Kyle Walker a few minutes from full-time – but the Spaniard had the last laugh by nicking the ball from Walker, then squaring to Daniel Sturridge to tap in. On that occasion, he was more than capable of closing down a full-back.

Secondly, however, there’s a sense of bravado about Mourinho’s actions. Leaving Mata on the bench is justifiable for tactical reasons, but leaving him out of the 18-man squad entirely is inexplicable. Last week’s match against Fulham saw Oscar, Hazard and Andre Schurrle (seemingly Mourinho’s favoured three attacking midfielders) start, with Kevin de Bruyne and Willian on the bench.

But even if Mourinho considers Mata ill-suited to his first-choice system, what about the back-up plan, the alternative? Fulham were always likely to sit deep against Chelsea, which meant there was a decent chance Mourinho would need a more creative, intelligent playmaker capable of threading passes through the opposition defence. Mata is more capable of that than any of Chelsea’s other playmakers, and Mourinho’s grandstanding to make a political point meant his squad was weaker than necessary.

Third, however, there’s a suspicion that Mourinho dislikes Mata from a personal point of view. Ruud Gullit suggested something similar, prompting a spiky response from Mourinho – but when a manager ignores such a high-profile player to such an extent, there’s often something more private involved.

There are two possible angles here – perhaps Mourinho is suspicious of Mata’s friendship with some of the Real Madrid players he fell out with last season. Alternatively, he’s concerned that Chelsea’s new generation of (generally Spanish-speaking) players have too much influence in the dressing room, and wanted to return to a squad led primarily by John Terry, Frank Lampard and Ashley Cole – Mourinho’s old favourites.

These remain conspiracy theories, but it’s odd that Mourinho informed close journalists that he was prepared to listen to offers for Luiz and Mata before the season had even started. That suggests a deep-rooted opposition to these players, rather than a gradual dissatisfaction based upon poor performances.

Knowing Mourinho, Mata will return in about a month, Mourinho will exaggerate his increased defensive contribution, and declare him a more complete player when the goals and assists inevitably follow, almost taking credit for his form. This period is surely the means to an end, rather than the end itself – Mata is too good to ignore for much longer.

Posted in , Premier League, Zonal Marking | 6 comments

September 27th, 2013 by Michael Cox

  • Pats

    I thought that was a brilliant summary f the whole ‘mata’ saga. Recent ‘news’ from the ‘jounos’ now claim that Mourinho was prepared to ‘sacrifice’ Mata and Luiz (and torres) to generate money for his new signings.

  • wishusmashinge

    indid mourinho is the special one but let him understand that the whole of the previous season was in the hands of mata.So to speak most of the goals for came from that spaniard.let mou put aside personal issues and capitalise mata plz.what z that style of play talented player lyk mata wl fail cope up today.

  • sabawaleklazik

    ourinho will exaggerate his increased
    defensive contribution, and declare him a more
    complete player when the goals and assists
    inevitably follow, almost taking credit for his form.

    Very funny but a classic mourinho tactics

  • mark

    Mata is overrated by the English media same as David Silva hazard etc, the here wants the best players in the BPL and ssomtimes they have to create this hype with certain players at certain big clubs, why not so much hype around Carzola or Valencia is have these two in my team over hazard and Mata

  • GrandStand

    I expect better from you Michael. No one seems to have followed up on the fact that Mourinho’s judgment on Casillas has been vindicated this year. But it doesn’t suit the narrative of Mourinho as the petty, war monging narcisist. At Bayer, Heynkess picked a fight with both Robben and Ribery, at some point dropping Robben while Simione did the same with Thuran. In both instances they were key creative players in teams that were all close, but never quite winners. Both times the there was a drastic change from decent teams going forward to excellent machines which added trophies to their undoubted quality. But as is always the case with Mourinho, it’s unfashionable to give him any credit. You’ve already pre-empted any credit he may have gotten. Amazingly biased from a guy I pretty much swear by on football matters.

    • swiffer

      You are obviously a Mourinho fanboi, of course it stings to hear criticism.

Daily Betting Offers

Bet a winner at 3/1 or greater on the 7.15pm from Haydock today and get a free bet from Betfair

Back a winner at 4/1 or more on any live race on C4 to receive a risk free bet on the next.

Get up to 100% bonus on your European Soccer accumulators (Including Premier League).

Double odds if your first goalscorer bet scores in the first 20 mins in Champions League games

Bet on the FA Cup Final with Betfair for a money back as a free bet offer on losing stakes

Bet on 1st goalscorer with Betfred and get an odds boost if he goes onto score twice or a hat-trick

Free Bets App

Search on the go for a free bet that suits you with the app.
Search by Amount or by Bookie.

Kev Lard

Kev Lard - Comic Strip

View our weekly Hapless sports character Kev Lard in his latest exploits

Click here to see Kev »